Few introductions to the major leagues can match what Ted Breitenstein accomplished on October 4, 1891.
On that chilly afternoon in St. Louis, the 22-year-old left-hander made the first start of his major league career for the St. Louis Browns, the franchise that would eventually become the Cardinals. By the end of the day, he had thrown a no-hitter.
More than a century later, it remains one of the most extraordinary debuts in baseball history.
The young pitcher did not even realize what he had done until the game ended. His teammates carefully avoided mentioning the no-hitter as the game progressed, fearful that talking about it might jinx him. Breitenstein later recalled that he was simply focused on getting the next hitter out.
“I was too busy worrying about the next batter to care what had happened before,” he remembered years later.
It was only after the final out that his teammates began congratulating him and explained what had happened. While he stood trying to absorb the news, they carried him off the field on their shoulders. In one afternoon, a local St. Louis kid had become a baseball sensation.
Breitenstein’s story was deeply rooted in St. Louis. Born on June 1, 1869, he was the son of German immigrants and grew up in a city where baseball was rapidly becoming a civic obsession. Before reaching the major leagues, he worked making cookstoves for the Wrought Iron Range Company and pitched for the company’s baseball team, appropriately named the Home Comforts. He was hardly the imposing figure fans might imagine when they think of a dominant pitcher. The freckle-faced redhead stood just 5-foot-9 and weighed little more than 140 pounds when he entered professional baseball. Yet what he lacked in size, he made up for with intelligence, determination, and an exceptional left arm.
His rise through the local baseball ranks earned him an opportunity to practice with the Browns as part of a group of promising amateur players. The chance eventually led to a roster spot and, ultimately, to one of the most memorable first starts in baseball history.
The no-hitter was only the beginning. After an uneven 1892 season, Breitenstein emerged as one of the premier pitchers in the National League. His breakthrough came in 1893, a year that dramatically changed baseball. Prior to the season, the pitching distance was increased to 60 feet, 6 inches. The adjustment caused scoring to soar throughout the league as many pitchers struggled to adapt.
Breitenstein thrived. Despite playing for a team that finished near the bottom of the standings, he led the National League with a 3.18 ERA. The accomplishment was so impressive that Alfred H. Spink, founder of The Sporting News, later declared, “Theodore Breitenstein was at one time the greatest left-handed pitcher in America.”
That assessment did not seem exaggerated to those who watched him pitch during the 1890s. Hall of Fame outfielder Wee Willie Keeler offered a similarly glowing evaluation in 1897.
“He has terrific speed, sharp curves, and there is not a pitcher in the league that fields his position better,” Keeler said.
Breitenstein’s greatness becomes even more apparent when viewed through the lens of the teams he pitched for. The Browns were often among the weakest clubs in baseball, yet year after year, they remained competitive largely because of their hometown ace. From 1893 through 1896, Breitenstein accounted for 43 percent of the team’s victories. It was an astonishing burden for one player to carry.
The most remarkable example came in 1895, when the Browns won just 39 games all season. Breitenstein won 19 of them.
His 30 losses that year remain one of the highest single-season totals in major-league history, but the statistic says more about the weakness of the club than the quality of the pitcher. In fact, rival teams throughout baseball desperately wanted to acquire him. Sporting Life described him as a “good-natured, hard-working little wonder,” and despite the staggering loss total, virtually every team in the league recognized his value.
Modern fans accustomed to five-man rotations and pitch counts can scarcely comprehend Breitenstein’s workload. In 1894, he threw 447⅓ innings. Today, a 150-inning season makes a pitcher a workhorse. Breitenstein more than tripled that figure.
His workload remained one of the most remarkable in baseball history for well over a century. He routinely completed games, pitched on short rest, and was frequently asked to rescue teammates who had been knocked out of games early.
At one point during the 1894 season, Browns owner Chris Von der Ahe attempted to send Breitenstein back to the mound during the second game of a doubleheader after he had already completed the first game. Breitenstein refused and was promptly fined and suspended.
“The cranks have but a slight appreciation of the fearful strain a pitcher’s arm is subjected to,” he explained afterward.
Even by 19th-century standards, he knew he was being overworked.
His relationship with Von der Ahe was often contentious. The owner regularly worried about stories of Breitenstein’s drinking and inserted temperance clauses into his contracts. Those concerns were not entirely unfounded. One of the most famous stories of Breitenstein’s career occurred in 1893 when he reportedly became so intoxicated during a stop in Indiana that he refused to board the team’s train. Several teammates attempted to force him aboard but were unsuccessful. Eventually, he sobered up, returned to the club, and apologized.
Yet Breitenstein was hardly a carefree loafer. During the offseason, he worked as a machinist in a stove foundry and earned a reputation as a diligent laborer. One observer noted that there was “not a lazy bone in his body.” That combination of immense talent, personal flaws, and relentless work ethic made him one of the most fascinating players of his era.
Another source of his popularity was his partnership with catcher Heinie Peitz. The two German-Americans became known throughout baseball as the “Pretzel Battery,” one of the game’s most colorful nicknames. Their chemistry extended beyond simply throwing and catching.
Breitenstein and Peitz occasionally pretended to argue during critical moments of games. While the batter became distracted by the apparent disagreement, Peitz would secretly flash the sign for the next pitch. Then Breitenstein would quickly deliver the ball before the hitter regained his focus.
“We have pulled out of many a tight hole with that trick,” Breitenstein said.
The combination of gamesmanship and humor perfectly reflected the rough-and-tumble character of baseball during the 1890s.
After the 1896 season, the Browns finally sold Breitenstein to Cincinnati for a reported $10,000, an enormous sum at the time. The move transformed his career. Freed from carrying one of baseball’s weakest clubs, he immediately demonstrated what he could accomplish with better support around him.
He won 23 games in 1897 and 20 more in 1898. Then, on April 22, 1898, he added another historic accomplishment to his résumé by throwing the second no-hitter of his major league career against the Pittsburgh Pirates.
Even that achievement came with an unusual twist. On the very same day, Baltimore’s Jay Hughes also threw a no-hitter. It marked the first time in major league history that two no-hitters had been recorded on the same date.
Although Breitenstein enjoyed some of the finest seasons of his career in Cincinnati, St. Louis remained home. In 1901, he returned to the franchise, now known as the Cardinals. Unfortunately, years of extraordinary workloads had taken their toll. The pitcher who had once dominated National League hitters could no longer consistently summon his former brilliance. After just a few starts, his major league career came to an end.
His baseball journey, however, was far from over.
Breitenstein continued pitching successfully in the minor leagues for another decade, most notably with the New Orleans Pelicans. He remained effective well into his forties and even threw another no-hitter as a 40-year-old in 1909. His longevity became almost as impressive as his accomplishments in the major leagues.
As he aged, Breitenstein became an increasingly important source of baseball wisdom. Long before analytics and radar guns, he understood the value of changing speeds, studying hitters, and pitching intelligently.
When his wife, Ida, died in April 1935, the loss devastated him. Just eight days later, Breitenstein died of heart failure in his hometown of St. Louis. He was 65 years old.
Today, his name is largely forgotten outside the circles of dedicated baseball historians. Yet his story remains one of the most compelling in early Cardinals history. He was a hometown kid who worked in a stove factory, threw a no-hitter in his first major league start, carried struggling St. Louis teams on his shoulders, formed one of baseball’s most colorful batteries, and earned the admiration of teammates, opponents, and Hall of Famers alike. More than a century later, Breitenstein remains one of the most fascinating figures ever to wear a St. Louis uniform.
Give the gift of Cardinals history! The Trades That Made The St. Louis Cardinals is available now on Amazon.