Keith Hernandez arrived in St. Louis as an unheralded draft pick, but he left nearly a decade later as one of the most accomplished first basemen in Cardinals history. A National League batting champion, co–Most Valuable Player, World Series champion, and perennial Gold Glove winner, Hernandez embodied the combination of defensive brilliance, offensive consistency, and baseball intelligence that defined Cardinals baseball in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
Born October 20, 1953, in San Francisco and raised in nearby San Bruno, Hernandez grew up in a baseball household. His father, John Hernandez, had once been a promising prospect in the St. Louis Cardinals’ farm system before eye trouble ended his playing career. Baseball remained central to the family, and Keith spent countless hours honing his skills. In his autobiography, he recalled standing on the lawn as a child, throwing a tennis ball against the garage wall, imagining himself as a major league star.
The Cardinals drafted Hernandez in the 42nd round of the 1971 amateur draft, a selection that initially seemed insignificant. Hernandez himself later acknowledged how unusual his signing bonus was for such a late pick. “Usually, guys taken that late aren’t even signed,” he wrote.
The organization quickly learned it had made a wise investment. Hernandez moved steadily through the Cardinals’ farm system and debuted in the majors in 1974. Early on, his reputation centered as much on his glove as on his bat. Managers and teammates noticed how effortlessly he handled the responsibilities of first base. Years later, Whitey Herzog would reflect on Hernandez’s defensive brilliance, saying he was “the greatest defensive first baseman I’ve ever seen.”
Hernandez’s defensive excellence became a constant throughout his career. Between 1978 and 1988, he won 11 consecutive Gold Gloves, the longest streak ever by a first baseman and a remarkable testament to both his athleticism and his preparation. His fielding ability was not simply about quick reflexes or soft hands. Teammates often remarked on his positioning, his anticipation, and his deep understanding of opposing hitters.
Pitcher Bob Forsch once described how valuable Hernandez could be during games. “When Keith Hernandez talked out there, I listened,” Forsch recalled. Hernandez would sometimes approach the mound and explain how a hitter should be pitched. “He was very astute about watching hitters hit.”
While Hernandez quickly became known for his defense, his offensive development took a little longer. That changed dramatically in 1979. At age 25, Hernandez produced one of the most impressive seasons in Cardinals history. He batted .344 to win the National League batting title, led the league with 48 doubles and 116 runs scored, collected 210 hits, and drove in 105 runs. Just as important, he reached base at a remarkable .408 clip, one of the highest on-base percentages in the league that year and a reflection of the disciplined approach that defined his offensive game.
The season culminated in an unprecedented moment in baseball history. Hernandez and Pittsburgh’s Willie Stargell finished tied in the National League MVP voting – the first tie in the award’s history. Hernandez embraced the shared honor with humility. “A tie makes it all the better because Willie’s a great man,” he said. “It’s an honor just to have my name next to his.”
The MVP season elevated Hernandez from a promising player to the centerpiece of the Cardinals’ lineup. St. Louis rewarded him with a five-year contract worth roughly $3.8 million, making him the highest-paid player in franchise history at the time.
Hernandez remained a key figure in St. Louis throughout the early 1980s. Between 1979 and 1982, he was among the National League’s most consistent hitters, regularly finishing near the league leaders in batting average, doubles, and on-base percentage. By the time he left the Cardinals, he had compiled a .299 batting average in a St. Louis uniform and established himself as one of the club’s most dependable offensive performers. Modern statistical measures underscore his importance during those seasons: Hernandez accumulated more than 30 wins above replacement during his tenure with the Cardinals, placing him among the most valuable first basemen in franchise history.
His best moments with the Cardinals came during the club’s championship season in 1982.
That year, under Herzog’s aggressive “Whiteyball” style, the Cardinals combined speed, defense, and situational hitting to win the National League pennant. Hernandez served as the club’s steady offensive anchor, batting .299 with 94 RBIs while providing his usual Gold Glove defense at first base.
In the postseason, he was just as valuable. During the National League Championship Series against Atlanta, the Cardinals swept the Braves to reach the World Series. In the seven-game Fall Classic against Milwaukee, Hernandez drove in eight runs as St. Louis captured its first championship since 1967.
Despite his success, Hernandez admitted that the pressure of the World Series affected him deeply. Looking back on the decisive Game 7, he remembered standing at first base as closer Bruce Sutter prepared to secure the final outs.
“I had a pit, a knot, in my stomach,” Hernandez recalled. “I couldn’t even bend over to get in my fielding position. I was out there at first base thinking, ‘Don’t hit the ball to me.’”
The moment perfectly captured the emotional stakes of the championship run. When Sutter finally recorded the final out, the Cardinals had completed one of the most memorable seasons in franchise history—and Hernandez had been central to it.
Yet Hernandez’s relationship with the Cardinals was never entirely smooth. In his memoirs, Herzog wrote that by 1983, Hernandez remained an exceptional defender but had begun to change in other areas of his game.
“I’ve never seen a ballplayer bear down as much at first base as he does,” Herzog said. “But on offense, he was loafing.”
The manager also criticized Hernandez’s preparation habits, claiming that during batting practice he would sometimes return to the clubhouse to relax.
“His practice habits were atrocious,” Herzog wrote. “He’d come out for batting practice, then head back to the clubhouse to smoke cigarettes and do crossword puzzles.”
Hernandez strongly disputed those characterizations later in his career, insisting that crossword puzzles were simply a way to relax before games.
Despite the tension, Hernandez remained an outstanding player. Even Herzog acknowledged that Hernandez and George Brett were the two best hit-and-run hitters he had ever managed, adding that Hernandez was “a very intelligent ballplayer.”
Still, in June 1983, the Cardinals traded Hernandez to the New York Mets for pitchers Neil Allen and Rick Ownbey.
The news stunned many Cardinals fans. When the trade announcement appeared on the Busch Stadium message board, it was met with loud boos from the crowd. Hernandez, however, later said he had sensed the deal coming.
“I could tell a trade was coming,” he recalled. “I knew I wasn’t in Whitey’s good graces.”
The trade became one of the most debated transactions in Cardinals history. Herzog later defended the decision bluntly, saying that removing Hernandez from the clubhouse had been “addition by subtraction.”
Hernandez, for his part, always maintained a complicated affection for the organization that drafted and developed him. “I grew up a Cardinal,” he once said. “I was taught the Cardinal way to play… the pride it was to be a Cardinal.”
The trade did not mark the end of Hernandez’s success – it simply shifted the stage. In New York, he quickly became the stabilizing presence the Mets had been searching for. In 1984, his first full season with the club, Hernandez batted .311 with 15 home runs, won another Gold Glove, captured a Silver Slugger Award, and finished second in the National League MVP voting. The Mets won 90 games that season, their first strong showing in years, and Hernandez’s leadership and steady play were widely credited with helping transform the culture of the franchise.
Two years later, Hernandez again found himself at the center of a championship run. The 1986 Mets won 108 games and then survived a dramatic postseason that included a six-game National League Championship Series victory over the Houston Astros and a seven-game World Series triumph over the Boston Red Sox. Hernandez played a significant role throughout October. He collected seven hits and three RBIs in the NLCS and delivered key offensive moments in the World Series, including a two-run single in Game 7 that helped erase a 3–0 Boston lead.
Over the course of his 17-year major league career, Hernandez accumulated 2,182 hits, 162 home runs, and 1,071 RBIs while posting a .296 lifetime batting average and a .384 on-base percentage. Yet the foundation of that career was built in St. Louis.
During his nine seasons with the Cardinals, he had established himself as one of the finest players in the National League. He won the 1979 batting title with a .344 average, shared the league’s MVP Award with Willie Stargell, captured multiple Gold Gloves, and helped lead the Cardinals to the 1982 World Series championship. He is also one of the very few first basemen in Cardinals history to win both a batting title and a Most Valuable Player Award while wearing the uniform.
Those years also produced one of the most respected defensive reputations in baseball history. Whitey Herzog—who had clashed with Hernandez but never doubted his ability—once summed up his view of the first baseman simply: Hernandez was “the greatest defensive first baseman I’ve ever seen.”
Even after his playing career ended, Hernandez continued to maintain a connection to the game, becoming a broadcaster and one of the most recognizable figures in Mets history. Yet he never forgot where his career truly took shape.
“I grew up a Cardinal,” Hernandez once said, reflecting on the organization that drafted and developed him. “It was so ingrained in you the pride it was to be a Cardinal.”
In recognition of that legacy, Hernandez was inducted into the St. Louis Cardinals Hall of Fame in 2021, an honor that formally cemented his place in franchise history. The induction acknowledged not only his statistical achievements but also the influence he had on the Cardinals teams of the late 1970s and early 1980s.
Keith Hernandez’s career ultimately spanned far more than one city or one championship. But his years in St. Louis formed the foundation of everything that followed: the batting title, the MVP award, the Gold Gloves, and the championship that confirmed him as one of the most complete first basemen the game has ever seen.
Enjoy this post? Then you’ll love The Trades That Made The St. Louis Cardinals, available now on Amazon!